Compare HR and Payroll Software Providers
The Best HR & Payroll Software Alternative to Staffology
Looking for an HR solution that does more? HR Duo offers an all-in-one platform, combining shift scheduling, time tracking, payroll, and HR tools without needing multiple subscriptions.
In this comparison, we’ll break down the key differences between HR Duo and Staffology, demonstrating why HR Duo is the smarter choice for businesses looking to simplify their people operations and HR processes, whilst gaining complete workforce oversight.
Unified HR, Payroll, and Workforce Management
Staffology separates HR and payroll into different systems, forcing teams to juggle tools and duplicate data. HR Duo brings everything together. HR, payroll, time-tracking, talent management, and workforce operations in one connected platform. This gives you full visibility across people and operations, reduces admin, and helps HR teams work more strategically.
Compliance and Risk Management Built In
Staffology automates admin but doesn’t include compliance guidance or documentation. HR Duo includes model HR letters, policy templates, connected forms, and employee relations assistance, ensuring every HR process from onboarding to grievance, is compliant, documented, and audit-ready. This reduces legal risk and supports consistent, confident decision-making.
A Full AI HR Assistant
Staffology has no AI capability. HR Duo’s AI Assistant helps HR teams work faster, generating job descriptions, anonymising CVs, translating policies into 30+ languages, and drafting HR documents instantly. It saves hours of manual work each week while improving accuracy, compliance, and productivity.
On-Demand Pay and Payroll Flexibility
While Staffology runs accurate payroll, it doesn’t offer earned wage access. HR Duo’s full payroll engine includes On-Demand Pay, letting employees access their earnings early improving financial wellbeing and boosting retention. Payroll, RTI submissions, and payslip generation all run seamlessly within one system.
For Deskless, Multi-Site, and Shift-Based Teams
Staffology supports standard office-based users but lacks tools for mobile or multi-site teams. HR Duo includes digital rotas, geofence clock-ins, task management, and subcontractor oversight, making it ideal for shift-heavy sectors like manufacturing, healthcare, and construction. It helps ensure the right people are always in the right place, at the right time.
Performance Management
Staffology limits performance management to its highest-tier plan. HR Duo includes 360 reviews, one-to-ones, goal tracking, and improvement plans as standard, helping managers develop talent and drive engagement. Better structure means stronger performance, higher satisfaction, and lower staff turnover.
HR Duo
That's us!0 /month
Staffology
Other Provider8 /month
HR Duo
Staffology
Workforce Management
HR Software
Talent Management
Disclaimer: We’ve done our best to provide up-to-date and accurate information, as of March 2025, to help you compare your options. HR Duo provides this information to offer general insights and it shouldn’t be taken as professional advice. Some of the competitor data comes from competitor sites with the information they provide as well as platforms like Capterra and G2, and while we trust these sources, we haven’t independently verified every detail. We recommend doing your own research and seeking expert advice before making any big decisions.
Everything you need to manage your workforce
One HR platform tailored to your specific requirements. Get a custom price with the right blend of software, service and support.
Workforce Management
Everything to help manage your frontline teams, keep costs in check, and enhance operations.
What's Included:
-
Time-Tracking
-
Absence Management
-
Payroll
-
Shift Scheduling
-
Digital Rotas
-
Leave and Holiday
-
Employee Profiles
-
Analytics and Reports
-
Project Tracking
-
Payroll Reporting
-
Mobile App
-
Employee Self-Service
-
Geofence Clock-In
-
Subcontractor Management
-
Skills Matrix
-
Task Manager
-
Document Storage
-
Equipment Tracking
-
Permission Groups
-
Benefit Recording
-
Instant Messaging
-
Organisation Charts
-
Knowledge Centre
-
Language Translation
-
Platform Support
MoreLess
HR Assist
Everything to simplify your core HR processes and automate over 80% of your routine tasks.
What's Included:
-
HR Policy Templates
-
Employee Relations Assistance
-
On-Demand Pay
-
Connected Forms
-
Digital Contracts
-
Secure E-Signature
-
AI Assistant
-
Model HR Letters
-
Integrated Emails
-
Employee Assistance Programme
EmployPath
Everything you need to recruit the right people, improve performance, and nurture your people.
What's Included:
-
Applicant Tracking System
-
CV Anonymisation
-
Enhanced Onboarding
-
Performance Management
-
360 Reviews
-
One-to-ones
-
Improvement Plans
-
Goal & Objective Tracking
-
Performance Analytics
Choose the tools that work for you.
Create your customised HR platform today.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between HR Duo and Staffology?
Staffology is best known for its cloud-based payroll software and separate Staffology HR module. It provides strong automation for payroll calculations, RTI submissions, and compliance reporting but lacks deeper workforce and engagement tools.
HR Duo, on the other hand, is a complete HRMS and workforce management platform that unifies payroll, HR, compliance, time tracking, scheduling, onboarding, and performance management into one connected system. It includes HR Assist for compliance, Duo AI – a full HR assistant, and On-Demand Pay, making it a more comprehensive alternative to Staffology for growing UK and Irish businesses.
Is HR Duo better than Staffology for payroll and HR management?
Yes. Both platforms handle payroll, but HR Duo includes a full payroll engine integrated with HR data, digital rotas, time tracking, and leave management, ensuring complete accuracy and eliminating duplicate entry.
While Staffology Payroll focuses on automation, HR Duo connects payroll to real workforce data, providing real-time visibility of hours worked, pay costs, and employee attendance across sites.
Does HR Duo include On-Demand Pay (Earned Wage Access)?
Yes, and this is one of HR Duo’s biggest differentiators.
HR Duo’s integrated On-Demand Pay feature allows employees to access a portion of their earned wages before payday, improving financial wellbeing, retention, and employee satisfaction.
Staffology does not currently offer earned wage access, limiting flexibility for organisations with shift-based or hourly teams.
Which platform offers better HR compliance and employee relations support?
HR Duo is the stronger choice for compliance and HR risk management.
Staffology provides automation tools but doesn’t include compliance templates or legal guidance. HR Duo offers:
- Model HR letters and policy template
- Connected HR forms and digital contracts
- Employee relations assistance
- Secure e-signatures and audit-ready document storage
These features make HR Duo one of the most compliance-focused HRMS solutions in the UK, helping employers stay aligned with UK employment law and GDPR requirements.
Does HR Duo include AI tools like Staffology?
Staffology does not currently include AI functionality.
HR Duo includes Duo AI, a full HR assistant that supports real HR operations. Duo AI helps HR teams and managers:
-
Create job descriptions and performance reviews
-
Anonymise CVs for fair recruitment
-
Translate HR policies into 30+ languages
-
Generate HR documents instantly
-
Get real-time HR guidance and best practice answers
This makes HR Duo one of the first UK HR platforms to embed true AI functionality across recruitment, compliance, and HR management.
Is HR Duo better suited for shift-based or mobile workforces than Staffology?
Yes. HR Duo is purpose-built for deskless and shift-based teams. It includes digital rotas, geofence-enabled clock-ins, mobile time tracking, subcontractor management, and project tracking. Features missing from Staffology.
For businesses in manufacturing, construction, healthcare, and retail, HR Duo provides complete workforce visibility and scheduling control.
Can HR Duo replace Staffology as an all-in-one HR and Payroll platform?
Yes. HR Duo replaces both Staffology Payroll and Staffology HR by offering all the same functionality, and more, in a single system. HR Duo includes:
-
Payroll processing and RTI submissions
-
Employee profiles and analytics
-
Compliance management and HR templates
-
Performance management and engagement tools
-
On-Demand Pay and Duo AI
This means one login, one database, and no need for separate HR and payroll subscriptions.
Which platform offers better performance management tools?
HR Duo provides a broader and more structured approach to performance management.
While Staffology includes appraisals and training tracking in its higher-tier plans, HR Duo offers 360 reviews, one-to-ones, improvement plans, and goal tracking as standard. It links performance to company objectives and compliance processes, supporting a continuous feedback culture that drives engagement and retention.
How does HR Duo support compliance with UK employment law?
HR Duo is developed specifically for UK and Irish employment regulations. It supports HMRC RTI compliance, GDPR data protection, and UK Working Time Regulations (WTR).
Through HR Duo, users gain access to compliant templates, forms, and contracts that reduce legal risk and help managers handle employee issues correctly, something Staffology users often need external support for.
Why do businesses switch from Staffology to HR Duo?
Businesses switch because HR Duo consolidates what Staffology separates. With Staffology, HR and payroll operate as two distinct products, often requiring separate subscriptions and integrations.
HR Duo provides one unified platform that automates over 80% of HR admin, connects payroll and workforce data, reduces compliance risk, and improves employee engagement through Duo AI and On-Demand Pay. For organisations seeking a single source of truth for HR, payroll, and workforce operations, HR Duo offers a stronger, more scalable alternative.
Is HR Duo a better long-term investment than Staffology?
Yes, because it reduces reliance on multiple systems, ensures compliance, and saves time.
By combining HR, payroll, compliance, and workforce management in one platform, HR Duo delivers measurable ROI through reduced admin, lower compliance risk, and improved employee retention.
For growing UK businesses seeking a modern, all-in-one HRMS and payroll solution, HR Duo is a more future-proof choice than Staffology’s modular approach.













